Best Baking Trays

Our editors independently research the best products online to produce this list. We may receive commission on purchases made from the links below but this will never affect our product choices.

---

Baking trays are an often overlooked kitchen essential. They are indispensable for baking and often double up as a roasting dish. Place one under any item you are cooking, and you’ll also save your oven from needing an intensive deep clean should it bubble over.

How We Compared Baking Trays

To find the right baking trays, we considered multiple factors, including:

• Construction Materials
• Non-Stick Coating
• Maximum Oven-Safe Temperature
• Ease of Cleaning
• Durability

Our team planned comparison points and specifically looked for products that would cater to all kinds of needs. We spent countless hours researching, consulting customer reviews and comparing features to come up with this list.

Baking Tray Reviews

HaWare Oven Tray Set (Editor’s Choice)

This oven tray set is our editor’s choice thanks to its high-quality construction, practical design and easy-to-clean finish. Moreover, as this is a two-piece set, it is really convenient and an excellent option for replacing your current, worn-out baking trays.

These baking trays from Haware are crafted from durable stainless steel, so they are made to last. At 40cm long by 30cm wide, they are a good size for cooking for a crowd or dishes that require a lot of space. In addition, thanks to their 2.5cm depth, you can use them for a wide variety of recipes, including oven-roasted dishes. 

With rounded corners and a smooth mirror finish, these baking trays make for easy cleaning and food removal. Their rolled edges also ensure that there are no sharp angles you may find on other models that could damage your fingers. All in all, this is a great buy and one of the very best options on the market. 

Le Creuset Non-Stick Baking Tray (Luxury Choice)

You can’t go wrong with this non-stick baking tray, our luxury choice. Do you appreciate highly functional kitchen accessories of the highest quality? Then this is the option for you.

Made by Le Creuset, one of the most prestigious cookware brands, this baking tray is made from heavy-gauge carbon steel. Not only is it highly durable, but also warp-resistant, and it heats through evenly. Moreover, it is oven-safe up to 240 degrees Celsius and comes with elevated sides, making it suitable for almost all dishes. 

This baking tray is also easy to clean, and your food will be easy to remove. It benefits from a PFOA-free non-stick coating that lasts. It is also utensil-safe with care and features secure-hold silicone inserts to improve grip. Thanks to its high-quality design and construction, it’s by far the best top-end baking tray choice. 

Lets Cook Cookware Teflon (Best Value)

This set is our best value choice. As such, it’s worth checking out if you’re looking to replace your baking trays without overspending. 

This set from Lets Cook Cookware consists of two carbon steel baking trays, and it is ideal for any household. Whether you need two trays for large family meals or just like to have a spare to hand, you can’t argue with this set’s value. Each unit measures 32cm by 22cm and has raised edges. This makes them suitable for use in various ovens and for cooking a wide range of dishes. You can use them for baking and roasting as they are oven-safe up to 230 degrees Celsius. 

Thanks to their classic Teflon non-stick coating, these baking trays make food removal extra easy. Plus, as they are dishwasher-safe, they are straightforward to clean after use.

GreenLife Non-Stick Baking Tray (Best for Material)

Are you fed up with boring black or silver-coloured baking trays? This non-stick baking tray set features a vibrant turquoise outer finish that is sure to liven up your kitchen. 

This baking tray set by Greenlife features two heavy-duty carbon steel trays, oven-safe up to 200 degrees. Not only do these baking trays heat evenly, but they also feature a PFAS-free ceramic non-stick coating. This makes it easy to remove your food from them, as well as making them effortless to clean. With less food residue sticking to your baking tray, you can simply wipe it clean and rinse.  

Thanks to their reinforced rims, they are stable and robust. If you are looking for a good-quality replacement option with a difference, this coloured set makes a top choice.

Prestige Inspire Oven Tray (Best for Sturdiness)

Unlike many baking trays on the market, this model is really sturdy thanks to its heavy-gauge carbon steel construction. This is the best choice if you are searching for a good heavy, durable baking tray.

Not only is the Prestige Inspire Oven Tray strong and reliable, but it also provides better browning. This is down to its special Cushion Smart surface that improves airflow. You can use it at oven temperatures up to 240 degrees Celsius, making it a great all-rounder. Moreover, its non-stick coating ensures that you can remove your food easily and with minimal residue.

Simple to clean, this baking tray is also dishwasher-safe, saving you time and effort. Its rolled edges make it nice and safe to handle, so you won’t have to worry about catching your fingers on sharp edges. This model will make an excellent upgrade if you are fed up with weak, flimsy baking trays. 

ProChef Baking Tray Set (Best Trio)

This baking tray set is our best trio pick, ideal if you tend to do a lot of oven baking. It consists of three durable carbon steel baking trays. Each tray measures 38cm long by 27cm wide, so you’ll be able to accommodate a wide variety of food types. 

Each baking tray in this ProChef Set benefits from a non-stick coating. This makes food removal a breeze and ensures they are easy to clean. Moreover, these baking trays are also dishwasher-safe for extra convenience. 

Oven-safe up to 230 degrees Celsius, you can use them for high-temperature baking and roasting, as well as at lower temperatures. As with all metal oven trays, you can also put them in your freezer – this makes having a set of three a handy option. 

Circulon Momentum (Best for Ease of Cleaning)

This square baking tray is our best choice for ease of cleaning. It features a special non-stick system, reducing food residue and is also dishwasher-safe. So, if you’ve had enough scrubbing your baking trays, this pick will make a great change. 

Unlike other options, this model has a specially textured, Total non-stick coating. Not only does this ensure that your food won’t stick, but it also makes this baking tray longer lasting than your average tray. Thanks to its alloy steel construction, it is solid and stable, too. 

Oven-safe up to 230 degrees, you can use this baking tray for high- and low-temperature baking and roasting. Thanks to its superior 0.6mm thickness, this model resists warping, unlike some thinner, flimsy models. If you are looking for a strong and highly durable baking tray that is also easy to clean, then this Circulon Momentum Baking Tray is the one to go for.

How to Choose a Baking Tray

With so many products to choose from, selecting the best baking tray isn’t as easy as it may seem. Here’s our guide on what to look out for when deciding the ideal one for you. 

Construction Materials

Pay close attention to what your baking tray is made of, as its construction will affect its durability and performance. Carbon steel and stainless steel are two of the best baking tray construction materials.

• Carbon steel – a popular choice, carbon steel baking trays are highly durable and lightweight. They are good heat conductors and a great non-stick option. 
• Stainless steel – stainless steel baking trays are hard-wearing and non-reactive. They will also be extremely long-lasting and resistant to corrosion. 

Non-Stick Coating

For easy cleaning and effective food removal, you may wish to look out for a tray with a non-stick coating. Just like your other non-stick cookware, you will need to take care of the finish to ensure that it doesn’t become damaged or scratched. Search for coatings that are free from potentially harmful chemicals. You should also consider ones with extra non-stick layers for better durability. 

Maximum Oven-Safe Temperature

Do you tend to do a lot of high-temperature baking? If so, make sure that your baking tray can take the heat. Otherwise, it may warp, which could ruin your recipe, although your tray should return to normal upon cooling. 

Ease of Cleaning

Traditional baking trays have a bad reputation for being very hard to clean. A non-stick version will help make cleaning easy, as you’ll be able to remove your food with no residue. Dishwasher-safe models will also make cleaning up after cooking much faster and hassle-free. 

Durability

No one wants to have to replace their baking trays every couple of months. Make sure you choose an excellent durable option made from a heavy-gauge material. You should also check that it can withstand your average oven cooking temperatures. Non-stick models with several layers of coating will also last longer in better condition.

Summary

If you’re still undecided, we recommend going for our editor’s choice and overall favourite, the HaWare Oven Tray Set. This two-piece baking tray set is made from durable and sturdy stainless steel for extra longevity. Its smooth mirror finish means that you will be able to easily remove your food from its surface, resulting in less residue and time spent cleaning. Its 2.5cm deep rim makes this set an ideal choice for baking and roasting, while its smooth corners ensure food won’t get trapped for easier cleaning.